You’ll hear people say, “Don’t pay any attention to your book reviews—they’re meaningless.”
Well, I beg to differ. I find both positive and negative reviews often helpful. Not all of them, of course. There are mean-spirited people who leave nasty reviews. There are readers who download Kindle books free just because they’re free even though it isn’t the type of book they would ever read. And they have the gall to leave a review—a negative review, of course.
No, those reviews should be ignored. Let’s focus on the two types of reviews that can be helpful.
- Rave reviews. As authors, we love positive feedback. We thrive on compliments and accolades. The 5-star reviews with a gush of praise let us know we have an audience and they enjoy our stories or find our nonfiction books useful. Positive reviews keep us writing. We can use phrases from these reviews in our promotion—for back cover copy, etc. And numbers of these reviews serve to influence other readers—or at least we can hope they do.
- Critical reviews. Oh do we hate to see a minimal line of stars next to a new review and we shudder when we read a complaint or unfavorable comment. Granted, some of them are a bit unfair. I’ve had readers ding one of my Klepto Cat Mysteries simply because they don’t like cats, they were uncomfortable with the discussion about the plight of feral cats, they disagreed with a word I used, etc. But I’ve also learned a lot from reviewers and reader-reviewers. I have used the wrong word. I have drawn outside the lines when it comes to being true to my genre. I have forgotten to cross a T or dot an i occasionally and I appreciate it when an astute reader or reviewer points it out.
Certainly, I’d rather they contact me personally rather than blast it on my Klepto Cat Mystery page at Amazon. I’m very easy to find on the Internet. But I do take all comments to heart and act on those that it makes sense to. If it is a suggestion about my style of writing or the way my storyline flows, for example, and if I agree, I consider this for the next book in the series.
If you’re an author, you’ve probably learned that not every reader sees the same thing in the books they read. If you’re not yet published, prepare yourself. Take a look at the reviews for my Klepto Cat Mystery books and you’ll see what I mean. http://amzn.to/1kAI8I2